Google’s Own Phone Won’t Resolve Android Fragmentation

Main Image
  • Like
  • Comment
  • Share

Google is reportedly taking matters in its own hands and working on a “Google Phone” where it takes control of both hardware and software side of the equation. Since the news broke out, I have read more than a few articles explaining how this is a great move, and how this will help curb the perennial problem of Android fragmentation. After all, that’s how iPhone does it, no?

Now, I totally love the Idea of a Google-made phone, but I don’t think it will patch up the fractured Android ecosystem.

Android latest distribution chart June 2016

For those new to the subject: More about Android Fragmentation

“The very fact that you are allowed to download and modify Android however you please and sell it on any product means fragmentation. That is to say, there will be different permutations and combinations of Android hardware and software which would be very hard to control and even harder to update to a same version.

If Google rolls out a new version update, it might not bode well with a particular set of hardware and might break things. OEMs have to extensively test update for each device separately and with shorter launch cycles and diminishing price margins, this is not in their best interest. So whatever features Google rolls out takes at least one year to reach all categories of consumers.”

Nexus couldn’t do it

We already have Google made phones, popularly known as Nexus phones. Google not only handles software and software updates but also guides manufacturers and works closely with them on the associated hardware.

The end product is awesome more often than not. Despite all its flaws, the Nexus 5X is still a personal favorite to me. It still feels so much better than all other spec-monsters selling in the adjacent price bracket. It’s a fantastic, compact phone that simply works.

Nexus 5X and 6P

Also Read: Nexus 5X Full Review

However, not everyone buys a Nexus. Android ecosystem has always been about options. And understandably, there are a dozen other manufacturers with extensive product portfolios catering to different tastes, fighting aggressively for every inch of the pie, and without any real motivation for delivering Android updates.

Even with Motorola and Nexus phones giving stock Android experience across all price ranges, the Android Marshmallow adoption is slow, perhaps slower than even Android Lollipop.

Only iPhones run iOS, Google has partners

To assume that after Google steps into the smartphone game they will instantly rule the roost with the lion’s share of the Android smartphone pie, and we will have updates pushing all around is wishful thinking.

iOS adoption chart May 2016

iOS can quote great adoption figures primarily because it runs only on one brand handsets (iPhones). Android on the other hand, covers a vast expanse. This diversity means that Google Phone won’t be the sole option for Android consumers. Its market share will be limited, and so will be the corresponding impacts on latest Android adoption.

Not the first Google Phone

Remember Moto X? A powerful, ergonomic, meticulously designed handset that received rave reviews? Moto X was a smartphone coming from Google-owned Motorola, and it dared to be a phone with dual core processor in an otherwise quad-core world.

original Moto X

Like any other phone, it wasn’t perfect. But, you can’t expect perfection from the upcoming Google phone either. Google has a tendency of not playing to the galleries, which in my opinion, was one reason why the Android One project didn’t take off.

The point being, people didn’t instantly ditch other OEM phones simply because they had an option from Google. That’s not how it works.

Fragmentation still needs to be addressed

Yes, Android fragmentation is a huge pain in the neck. With a small share of people actually running Android Marshmallow, new OS features that developers work on and add to their apps aren’t fully appreciated. Google’s Android vision gets passed down to masses a whole year later. Not to mention, the security challenges involved in a fractured software ecosystem. But Google has somewhat resorted to an alternative solution.


The OS has been broken down to apps, and many key changes in new Android versions are passed on to all Android users via Playstore or Google Playservies updates. For instance, changes in App drawer can be delivered to people running different Android versions simply with an update to Google Now launcher. This does help soften the blow but is still an incomplete solution.

More than ever before, Google needs to solve Android fragmentation. And making more stock Android options available in the form of its own branded phones might even help, but that alone can’t solve Android fragmentation. Unless Google unleashes a whole series of phone spanning a wide price range, Google branded phone won’t be conducive to a real change any more than a Nexus.

Also read: 8 Most Important Announcements From Google I/0 2016

Deepak SinghDeepak Singh
Deepak has more than 8 years of experience in covering technology for several eminent publications in India. He currently leads an enthusiastic team of young writers at Smartprix and tries to uphold the highest quality standards.

Related Articles

ImageHot Scoop: Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 6 Pricing Revealed Ahead of Official Release

Samsung’s next clamshell foldable, the Galaxy Z Flip6, will launch next month at Galaxy Unpacked. While everyone awaits the official announcement, we’ve managed to uncover the Galaxy Z Flip6’s pricing and variants for the US market in association with OnLeaks. Brace yourselves—unfortunately, the pricing is higher than expected. Galaxy Z Flip6 Price Leaked  The Galaxy …

ImageHow to use Google’s Find My Device feature to locate your lost Android phone

Smartphones are an integral part of everyone’s life today and it brings a sudden trauma when your hands don’t find the phone in your pocket. Also, there are several occasions when you accidentally forget your phone on the office desk, cab, or at a shop counter. But if you are an Android owner, you can …

ImageGoogle rolls out Android 13: Check out Android 13 top features, list of eligible devices

Google recently created a buzz in the industry with the release of the Android 13 operating system for the Pixel smartphones. The OS is only available for the latest generation of Pixel phones – Pixel 6, 6a, and 6 Pro. These handsets, after installing Android 13 once, will not be able to get Android 12 …

ImageGoogle I/0 2024: AI-Powered Scam Call Detection Arrives on Android Phones This Year

At the I/O developer conference on Tuesday, Google announced that it is working on implementing advanced security measures to protect Android users from telephone scams. Google is testing a new call monitoring feature that will alert users of potential fraudulent activity during calls and prompt them to end the communication. The new feature, powered by …

ImageDo The Tensor G3 SoC And Seven Years Of Android Updates Make The Google Pixel 8a A Worthy Successor?

In a surprising turn of events, Google has announced its Pixel 8a ahead of its anticipated launch during I/O 2024. The smartphone succeeds the capable Pixel 7a and has all the photography and videography perks of the Pixel series. Although the phone offers a refreshed design, runs on Google’s flagship Tensor G3 SoC, and features a …


Be the first to leave a comment.