Consumer Court Fines These Smartphone Manufacturer And E-Commerce Company For Selling Used Phone

Main Image
  • Like
  • Comment
  • Share

Even though online shopping is mostly safe, there are a few instances where customers have happened to receive used, defective, or entirely different products from what they ordered. While the involved companies often make amends, especially when the product isn’t expensive, there are hundreds of cases where the customer didn’t get a timely response. In such situations, customers always have the option to appeal to the consumer court. However, people often don’t go down this road due to a lack of awareness.

Here’s What Happened

In a recent case where a customer received a used smartphone from a popular e-commerce platform, the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission ruled a verdict in favor of the customer. In July 2023, Ashwani Chawla ordered a new OnePlus 11R 5G via Flipkart from the seller Bathla Teletech. However, after a few days of receiving the product, Chawla started facing several problems. Upon visiting the service center, he realized the phone wasn’t new.

Per the record dated August 8, 2023, the service center discovered that the phone was activated on March 2, 2023, over four months before Chawla received it on July 17. The service center advised him to take this up with OnePlus and Flipkart. However, the complainant purchased a new smartphone after receiving no replies from the manufacturer and the e-commerce platform. Further, he also decided to inform the State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission at Chandigarh.

Commission Concluded That The Phone Was Old

After going through all the records, the Commission concluded that Chawla received a used phone as a brand new phone months after its activation date. Further, the Commission also criticized the two companies, stating that “the Opposite Parties acted themselves showed that they are least concerned about the customer grievance redressal but are just concentrated upon earning profits through misleading the public.”

It’s worth noting that Chawla received two invoices upon ordering the phone. While the first included the phone’s cost, shipping, and handling charges, the customer also received another invoice for an additional Rs. 49 handling fee. The Commission also took this into account and held it as an unfair trade practice. Further, the regulatory body has also imposed a fine of Rs. 30,000 on all the parties involved and asked them to refund the Rs. 40,941 Chawla paid for the phone and the Rs. 49 additional charges.

You can follow Smartprix on TwitterFacebookInstagram, and Google News. Visit smartprix.com for the most recent newsreviews, and tech guides.

Shikhar MehrotraShikhar Mehrotra
Shikhar Mehrotra is a seasoned technology writer and reviewer with over five years of experience covering consumer tech across India and global markets. At Smartprix, he has authored more than 1,700 articles, including news stories, features, comparisons, and product reviews spanning automobiles, smartphones, chipsets, wearables, laptops, home appliances, and operating systems. Shikhar has reviewed flagship devices such as the iPhone 16, Galaxy S25+, and Sennheiser HD 505 Open-Ear headphones. He also contributes regularly to Smartprix’s growing automotive section.

With a deep understanding of both iOS and Android ecosystems, Shikhar specializes in daily tech news, how-to explainers, product comparisons, and in-depth reviews. His DSLR photography in product reviews is recognized as among the best on the team.

Before joining Smartprix, Shikhar wrote for leading publications including Forbes Advisor India, Republic World, and ScreenRant. He holds a Bachelor of Arts in Journalism and Mass Communication from Amity University, Lucknow.

Related Articles

Image2026 Maruti Suzuki Brezza Spied With Revamped Front Bumper Design And New Alloy Wheels

Remember how an SUV was spied testing near Manali last month? Well, it looks like the location is a favorite among automakers for testing upcoming cars, as yet another model has been spotted there. This time, it is the 2026 Maruti Brezza facelift, which is expected to arrive sometime next year. Also Read: Maruti Suzuki …

ImageBengaluru’s consumer court asks Apple India to pay 1 Lac as damages to an iPhone 13 owner

Bengaluru’s consumer court ordered Apple India to pay a sum of INR 1,00,000/- to one of the customers after he sued them for unfair trade practices and for hardship caused In October 2021, Awez Khan bought an Apple iPhone 13 at INR 79,999/- with a one-year warranty. However, the phone’s battery and speaker stopped working …

ImageHow to file a complaint in a consumer court in India? Read on to know everything about it

In today’s age, online shopping and digital transactions have become a common practice in India. Ever since Covid enforced a lockdown, the dependence on online e-commerce portals for shopping and doing other money transactions has increased. But this doesn’t come without its share of flaws as many a time consumers have to go through a …

ImageGovernment Warns Consumers Against “Drip Pricing” Practice Prevalent On E-Commerce Platforms

The Department of Consumer Affairs and the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA) have formally warned consumers about drip pricing and other related “dark patterns.” The authorities have already established several guidelines regarding the final payable amount to be displayed upfront, which helps consumers in the decision-making process. Also Read: 20 Essential Government Apps for Indians …

ImageLava Agni 4 With Dimensity 8350 Chipset, 120Hz AMOLED Screen, And 50MP Primary Camera Launched In India

The Indian smartphone manufacturer Lava has launched a new mid-range handset, the Lava Agni 4. With its capable chipset, a 50MP primary camera, and a comprehensive AI suite, the smartphone offers a feature-rich alternative in the Rs. 20,000-25,000 segment. It will be available soon via the popular e-commerce platform Amazon. Also Read: Realme GT 8 …

Discuss

Be the first to leave a comment.